Steel water bottle with a blue sleeve filled at a cast-iron public fountain, walkers in the background
Cleo
All services →
Online toolsYou have a regulatory team
Product compliance assessmentThe legislation that applies to your product, what is still missing and what to do, per product and per market.Product monitoringSee the demo →The texts that apply to your products and the ones that change, within the agreed monitoring scope.
Not sure which option fits? We can help you choose.Free consultation →
Turnkey servicesYou have no one in-house
CE markingTechnical documentation and draft EU declaration of conformity, which the manufacturer signs.EU authorised representativeAn operator established in the Union to sell your products in Europe: written mandate, address, file, authorities.
Case studiesWork we have done with our clientsBlogRegulatory news and analysisRegulatory atlasThe official sources we track, country by country
About
EN·FRWhatsAppBook a demoGet started→
resources / Product Compliance

7 October 2026 · 6 min read · by Naomie Halioua

↖ all articlesNaomie HaliouaNaomie Halioua
Co-founder & CTO, AI Research
7 October 2026 · 6 min readProduct Compliance

A question about your product’s compliance?

Tell us about your product and the markets you want to enter.

WhatsApp ↗Free consultation ↗

PepsiCo recalled 122,021 cases of Gatorade on 25 September over two color additives that are still legal to sell: US law only requires naming them on the label, and this time the label didn't, right as the industry races to phase both out by year end

On 25 September 2026, PepsiCo voluntarily began recalling 122,021 cases of 28-ounce Gatorade Lemon Lime, Lemon Lime Zero, Orange and Orange Zero after finding the bottles contained FD&C Yellow No. 5 and/or FD&C Yellow No. 6 that were not declared on the label. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration classified the recall as Class II on 2 October 2026, its designation for products where exposure may cause temporary or medically reversible health effects, or where the probability of serious harm is remote. The affected lots, carrying best-by dates between April and June 2027, had already reached retailers in 37 states, among them Texas, California, Washington, Idaho, New York and Florida. Under 21 CFR 101.22(k)(2), FD&C certified color additives cannot be declared with the generic "artificial color" wording the rule allows for most other colorants: Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 each have to be named individually in the ingredient statement. Neither dye is unsafe to use in food; both remain federally authorized color additives, and the recall does not allege otherwise. What was missing was the one line of text the law specifically requires naming them, and it went missing while both dyes sit on a list the FDA is actively trying to retire.

What actually happened, and under which rule

PepsiCo's own recall, logged with the FDA on 25 September 2026, covers four 28-ounce Gatorade flavors: Lemon Lime, Lemon Lime Zero, Orange and Orange Zero. The stated reason is identical across all four: the bottles contain FD&C Yellow No. 5 and/or FD&C Yellow No. 6 that the label does not list. The FDA reviewed the case and assigned it Class II status on 2 October 2026, seven days after the recall began, placing it in the agency's middle tier of severity, above Class III (unlikely to cause any health problem) and below Class I (reasonable probability of serious harm or death). The recalled lots, identified by best-by dates running from April through June 2027, were distributed to retailers across 37 states before the recall was issued.

The rule behind the recall is narrower than it sounds. Under 21 CFR 101.22(k)(2), most color additives used in food can be declared on a US label with the generic terms "artificial color" or "artificial color added," without naming the specific substance. FD&C certified color additives are the exception: the regulation requires each one to be declared by its own name in the ingredient statement. FD&C Yellow No. 5 and FD&C Yellow No. 6 both fall in that certified category, alongside Red No. 40, Blue No. 1, Blue No. 2 and Green No. 3. A bottle that uses one of these six dyes cannot rely on a generic "color added" line; it has to say which one. That is the specific requirement PepsiCo's labels did not meet, and it is also the reason the fix is a paperwork correction rather than a reformulation: the dyes themselves did not have to be removed, only named.

Three details behind the recall

01

A recall with no hazard in the ingredient

Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 remain federally authorized color additives; the recall targets a missing label line, not an unsafe substance.

02

One rule, two words that are not allowed

21 CFR 101.22(k)(2) lets most color additives hide behind "artificial color"; the six FD&C certified dyes, Yellow 5 and 6 included, must each be named.

03

Seven days to a Class II label

PepsiCo began the recall on 25 September 2026; the FDA assigned its Class II classification seven days later, on 2 October 2026.

22 Apr 2025

HHS and the FDA announce a voluntary initiative asking the food industry to phase out six synthetic color additives, including Yellow No. 5 and No. 6, from the US food supply by the end of 2026.

25 Sep 2026

PepsiCo voluntarily begins recalling 122,021 cases of 28-ounce Gatorade Lemon Lime, Lemon Lime Zero, Orange and Orange Zero for undeclared Yellow No. 5 and/or No. 6.

2 Oct 2026

The FDA classifies the recall as Class II, its middle severity tier.

7 Oct 2026

This article is published; PepsiCo has not issued its own public statement explaining how the undeclared dyes reached labeled bottles.

31 Dec 2026

The industry's self-set target date, under the voluntary HHS-FDA initiative, for phasing Yellow No. 5 and No. 6 out of the US food supply.

The numbers behind the recall

One number is the scale of what PepsiCo pulled back. One is how far the affected lots had already traveled before anyone caught the labeling gap. The third is how little time separated the recall from the FDA's severity ruling.

122,021

cases of 28-ounce Gatorade across four flavors that PepsiCo voluntarily recalled starting 25 September 2026

37 states

had already received the affected lots at the time the recall was announced

7 days

between PepsiCo starting the recall on 25 September 2026 and the FDA's Class II classification on 2 October 2026

The real subject: a recall that is entirely a data problem, not a safety one

Most headline coverage of a food recall over an undisclosed color additive reads as a safety story: a dye turned up where it should not have been. That is not what happened here. Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 are both substances PepsiCo was allowed to use in Gatorade; nothing in the recall, or in the FDA's Class II designation, says otherwise. What triggered the recall was that the ingredient statement did not match the actual formulation: a line required by 21 CFR 101.22(k)(2), naming each certified color additive individually, was missing from labels already on shelves in 37 states. That is a product-data failure, a mismatch between what a bottle's label declares and what its contents actually are, not a formulation failure. Neither PepsiCo nor the FDA has published a public account of how the gap occurred, so this article does not assert a cause. What is independently confirmed is the timing: the recall lands in the middle of a voluntary industry-wide window, running from the HHS-FDA initiative's 22 April 2025 announcement to a self-set end-of-2026 target, during which food companies are actively reformulating to remove Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6 and four other synthetic dyes from their US product lines. A period when colorant formulas are changing faster than usual is also a period when the paperwork that is supposed to track those changes has less margin for error.

Why it matters for brands

Any brand selling packaged food or beverages in the US, not only large beverage makers, carries the same structural exposure PepsiCo's recall exposes: a label is a claim about formulation, and US law treats a handful of ingredients, the six FD&C certified color additives among them, as ones that cannot be described generically. That list exists alongside comparable by-name disclosure rules in other markets, from the EU's "may contain" and E-number regime to allergen-naming requirements nearly everywhere Cleo's clients sell. The operational risk is not the chemistry; it is the handoff between a formulation record and a label file, which has to be exact and current, including every time a supplier or plant swaps which specific colorant, sweetener or preservative goes into a recipe. Brands that are also reformulating ahead of the 2026 dye phase-out target face a second, compounding version of the same risk: a colorant change made for one reason, meeting a voluntary industry deadline, can silently create a labeling gap for an unrelated legal reason, the by-name declaration rule, if the formulation update and the label update are not tracked as one linked record. A product-data system that ties each SKU's actual formulation to its label text, and flags the specific additives that cannot hide behind a generic term, catches this class of error before a shelf date does.

Two ways to read the Gatorade recall

The narrow read

PepsiCo recalled 122,021 cases of Gatorade because two color additives in the bottles, Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6, were not declared on the label, and the FDA classified the recall Class II on 2 October 2026.

The structural read

Both dyes remain legal; the recall exists only because US law singles out six certified color additives for by-name declaration, and it landed in the middle of a voluntary industry-wide push to reformulate those same six dyes out of the food supply by the end of 2026, a window in which formulation changes outrunning label updates is the actual risk to manage.

Frequently asked questions

Are FD&C Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 unsafe, and is that why Gatorade was recalled?

No. Both are federally authorized color additives, and the recall does not allege either one is unsafe to consume. PepsiCo recalled 122,021 cases of 28-ounce Gatorade because the dyes were present in the product but not declared on the label, a labeling violation rather than a hazard finding. The FDA's Class II classification, assigned 2 October 2026, reflects that the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.

Why do Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 have to be named specifically, when other food colors can just say "artificial color"?

Under 21 CFR 101.22(k)(2), six FD&C certified color additives, Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6, Red No. 40, Blue No. 1, Blue No. 2 and Green No. 3, are excluded from the generic "artificial color" declaration that US law allows for most other colorants. Each one has to be named individually in the ingredient statement, which is the specific requirement the recalled Gatorade labels did not meet.

Is this recall connected to the FDA's push to phase synthetic dyes out of the food supply?

No official statement from PepsiCo or the FDA has confirmed a causal link, and this article does not assert one. What is confirmed is the timing: the recall falls within the voluntary window the HHS-FDA initiative opened on 22 April 2025, under which the food industry is working toward removing Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6 and four other synthetic dyes from the US food supply by the end of 2026.

Sources

  1. eCFR: 21 CFR § 101.22, "Foods; labeling of spices, flavorings, colorings and chemical preservatives," the primary legal source for the by-name declaration requirement covering FD&C certified color additives
  2. CBS News: "PepsiCo recalls 122,000 cases of Gatorade due to undeclared dyes," reporting the FDA-sourced case count, affected flavors and 25 September 2026 start date
  3. ABC7 New York / FDA: "FDA recalls 122,000 cases of Gatorade over undeclared dyes," independently corroborating the Class II classification date of 2 October 2026
  4. NBC News: "Gatorade recall: 122,000 cases pulled over undeclared dyes," independently corroborating the affected flavors and best-by date range
  5. Houston Chronicle: "Gatorade recall reaches 37 states, including Texas. Which drinks are affected?", independently corroborating the 37-state distribution footprint
  6. Good Morning America (ABC News): "122K cases Gatorade recalled due undeclared food dyes," independently corroborating the recall scope and reason
  7. Mayer Brown: "HHS and FDA Announce Plans to Phase Out Synthetic Food Dyes," law-firm client alert confirming the 22 April 2025 announcement and the end-of-2026 target for six synthetic dyes including Yellow No. 5 and No. 6
  8. Skadden: "FDA Seeks To Remove Petroleum-Based Dyes From US Food Supply," independently corroborating the voluntary phase-out initiative and its scope

Note on verification: this session's network access allows search but blocks direct page retrieval from fda.gov, cbsnews.com, abc7ny.com and several other news and government domains. Neither PepsiCo nor the FDA had published its own detailed public statement on this recall as of this article's publication date, so the case count, affected flavors, best-by date range, 37-state distribution, 25 September 2026 start date and 2 October 2026 Class II classification were confirmed through search-indexed excerpts of CBS News, ABC7 New York, NBC News, Houston Chronicle and Good Morning America, all of which report the same figures and dates from the FDA's enforcement record. The text of 21 CFR 101.22 was confirmed directly from eCFR, the official online compilation of the Code of Federal Regulations. The 22 April 2025 HHS-FDA voluntary phase-out initiative and its end-of-2026 target were confirmed through the Mayer Brown and Skadden client alerts, both independently describing the same announcement. This article does not assert a causal link between the recall and the phase-out initiative; only their overlapping timing is confirmed.

Frequently asked questions

Are FD&C Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 unsafe, and is that why Gatorade was recalled?

No. Both are federally authorized color additives, and the recall does not allege either one is unsafe to consume. PepsiCo recalled 122,021 cases of 28-ounce Gatorade because the dyes were present in the product but not declared on the label, a labeling violation rather than a hazard finding. The FDA's Class II classification, assigned 2 October 2026, reflects that the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.

Why do Yellow No. 5 and Yellow No. 6 have to be named specifically, when other food colors can just say "artificial color"?

Under 21 CFR 101.22(k)(2), six FD&C certified color additives, Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6, Red No. 40, Blue No. 1, Blue No. 2 and Green No. 3, are excluded from the generic "artificial color" declaration that US law allows for most other colorants. Each one has to be named individually in the ingredient statement, which is the specific requirement the recalled Gatorade labels did not meet.

Is this recall connected to the FDA's push to phase synthetic dyes out of the food supply?

No official statement from PepsiCo or the FDA has confirmed a causal link, and this article does not assert one. What is confirmed is the timing: the recall falls within the voluntary window the HHS-FDA initiative opened on 22 April 2025, under which the food industry is working toward removing Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6 and four other synthetic dyes from the US food supply by the end of 2026.

Related resources

White silicone facial brush under the tap, foam on its bristles, a blue scrunchie on the wrist
Product Compliance21 September 2026 · 6 min read

On 10 September, US regulators recalled the same hair dryer brush twice under two different brand names for missing a device mandatory since 1991: three more sellers of the identical product, on two other marketplaces, only got a warning, with no refund

On 10 September 2026, the US Consumer Product Safety Commission announced two separate recalls, for the Wantefully 2 in 1 Hair Dryer & Styler (seller: Guang Zhou) and the DHASUWT Hair Dryer and Blow Dryer Brush (seller: Junkins), both sold on Amazon.com and both carrying the same model number, XR-8801. Both lack the immersion protection device US law has required in hand-held hair dryers since Underwriters Laboratories added it to its safety standard in 1991, and that CPSC classified as an automatic federal hazard in 2011, under 16 CFR 1120.3(b)(1). What most coverage of the two recalls missed: CPSC had already flagged the identical hardware, under three further brand names, on two other marketplaces, five weeks earlier, on 13 August 2026. Those three sellers never responded, so CPSC could only warn consumers directly, with no recall and no refund.read ↗
Steel water bottle with a blue sleeve filled at a cast-iron public fountain, walkers in the background
Product Compliance6 August 2026 · 6 min read

On 20 July, Brazil's food regulator opened a consultation to let labels move information onto a QR code: the same draft rewrites which ingredients require a printed percentage on the pack

On 20 July 2026, Brazil's Anvisa opened Public Consultation No. 1,400/2026, proposing to revise RDC No. 727/2022, the rule governing labels on packaged food: for the first time, information Anvisa classifies as supplementary could move onto a QR code, while mandatory content would still have to be printed. Most coverage reads this as Brazil catching up to digital labeling. What it misses: the same draft rewrites the trigger test for the Quantitative Ingredient Declaration, making it mandatory whenever an ingredient is highlighted through words, images or graphics, so a brand cannot know what belongs on a QR code until it knows which ingredients that test now catches.read ↗
Child's wrist in a grey puffer jacket wearing a smartwatch with a blue strap, an adult hand holding theirs, the school behind
Product Compliance9 September 2026 · 6 min read

On 1 September, the EU proposed its first legal limit for the toxin behind a recall that reached at least 99 countries: the number for powdered infant formula is fixed, the number for liquid formula is a calculation every manufacturer has to run itself

On 1 September 2026, the European Commission published a draft regulation adding a maximum limit for cereulide, a heat-stable toxin behind a 2026 infant formula recall that WHO says reached at least 99 countries, to Regulation (EC) No 2073/2005: 1 microgram per kilogram in dried infant formula, with liquid formula checked against a manufacturer-calculated equivalent. Comments are open until 29 September 2026.read ↗
Grey lunch box with a blue lid open on a bench, rice and roasted vegetables, a hand holding a fork
Product Compliance19 July 2026 · 6 min read

South Africa's meat-analogue labelling rules took effect 18 July: a product needs 9% protein to legally call itself a 'meat alternative', and two different regulators enforce it depending on whether it crossed a border

South Africa's Government Notice R. 6436, published 18 July 2025 under the Agricultural Product Standards Act, became enforceable 18 July 2026. Most coverage treats it as a naming ban on terms like "chicken-style". What it misses: a product needs a lab-verified minimum of 9% protein before it can even use the words "meat alternative", and enforcement now forks between the Food Safety Agency for domestic sale and the Border Management Authority for imports, codifying a naming dispute the Food Safety Agency first threatened to enforce back in 2022.read ↗

something new in the works?

A scope and a price agreed for your product and markets.See the product in action↗
Cleo
pricingcase studyresourcesaboutbecome an expertfaqcontact

product compliance, handled.

anaelle@cleolabs.colinkedin ↗x ↗youtube ↗whatsapp ↗
© 2026 Cleo Corp SAS · Neuilly-sur-Seine
PrivacyTermsSecuritySite map
cleo / made to exist.